Writeup from aKademy

[Carlos Leonhard Woelz]

On Monday 30 August 2004 21:42, Aaron Seigo wrote:
> .... for this reason the SELECTing of the winning entry should probably be
> left up to the kde-artists group or else someone who is knowledgeable
> enough about both the upcoming CIG (Corporate/Community Identity
> Guidelines) and things such as icons and splashscreens to do a comparably
> proficient job of selecting something that works with the rest of KDE.
>
> would that be cool for everyone, namely:
>
> 	o Quality Teams helps coordinate these things
> 	o kde-artists does the winner selection

I agree. But I would word it differently: the kde-artist is part of the winner 
selection. The other part are the maintainers and developers of the 
application. It is possible to have requirements beyond the CIG, making this 
choice a complex one.

I would be cool with this only if the apps maintainers are cool with this. In 
the end, I believe the maintainer has the right to decide.

Cheers,

Carlos