Kanagram now in kdereview

[Danny Allen]

The idea of the kdereview module, as stated by thiago, is for translators to 
start working, documentation to be written, UI checked and the build is fixed 
for everyone.

With regard to Kanagram, the documentation is 95% finished, the UI stable and 
sane (along with the whole app being feature frozen), and I have not heard 
any reports of Kanagram not building.
Also, translators traditionally do the bulk of their work after the feature 
(and usually string freeze) so that their work is not obsoleted by new 
commits.

These facts mean that a short stay in kde-review for Kanagram is more than 
sufficient. Kanagram has been on the KDE 3.5 feature list for a long period 
of time now, with the aim of inclusion in 3.5.

The need of Kanagram to replace KMessedWords is great, with Kanagram being a 
highly enhanced application for the genre.

Not including Kanagram in kde-edu for the 3.5 release would be a great 
dis-service to our userbase, due to the myriad problems and unmaintainability 
of KMessedWords.

Therefore I must stress the case for swift inclusion in kde-edu, where the few 
remaining bugs can easily be fixed in time for the 3.5 release.

Danny
 

> Albert Astals Cid wrote:
> >> Do you plan to replace the KMessedWords application that is in kdeedu?
> >> Or just replace it as in "provide a better one"?
> >
> >What's the difference?
> 
> I should have phrased better: does he want to release inside kdeedu or in 
> extragear?
> 
> >NEW IN KDE: Kanagram - A word game to replace KMessedWords. Joshua Keel
> ><joshuakeel at gmail.com>
> >
> >> Besides, the time an app stays in kdereview should be a few weeks at
> >> least, in order for it to get the necessary fixing, checking,
> >> translating, documenting, etc. If so, then you won't make the feature
> >> freeze deadline, which is in 3 days.
> >
> >I have to agree here, 3 days seems too few, but as Kanagram is already
> > feature frozen (that is what is the deadline in 3 days), and Kanagram
> > is a nice improvement over kmessedwords, the existing bugs could be
> > fixed already in kdeedu as we have until at aprox October to fix. That
> > is the 2/3 weeks you ask for.
> 
> I just think it should have moved to kdereview 2-3 weeks ago if the 
> objective is to enter kdeedu before the feature freeze.

	
	
		
___________________________________________________________ 
Yahoo! Messenger - NEW crystal clear PC to PC calling worldwide with voicemail http://uk.messenger.yahoo.com