No more release schedules.

Andreas K. Huettel dilfridge at
Thu Jun 9 22:35:52 CEST 2011

Dear KDE upstream,

> Since KDE is the community, how can we do a KDE 4.8? And then Platform will
> call itself 5 if I understood correctly. So how do we call a new release
> schedule then?

I just read a very good novel where all such talk about "Software Collection" 
or "Platform" was aptly called "commercial bulshytt". I think many of us, 
including your "only-users", would appreciate it if you all there upstream 
would just stick to KDE, because that is what everyone uses. Nothing else.

> > Are you serious that you want to decouple the release of our
> > frameworks from
> > each other? THat would create a huge mess, extreme amounts of
> > overhead, be
> > very destructive to our community... This puzzles me as I know how
> > much you
> > love KDE.
> What does my love for KDE have to do with it? I think it's good for KDE to
> let each module set their freezes on their own, depending on which work
> flow they will adapt. If we decide it early the module maintainers have
> time enough to get used to creating the schedule.

Basically this is nothing but a dissolution of the KDE project as a whole. 
Sure, we'll end up with a lot of projects using and enhancing kdelibs (or 
whatever becomes of that), but there will be no coherence anymore.

> We can set a preferred release day twice a year, which every module can
> work to if they like.
> We can still package and release them if you like, that's independent of
> the schedules.

That both makes no sense. Suggestion 1 fails completely with the "if they 
like" part, since we all know already how much pain the "out of sync kdepim" 
caused. Suggestion 2 fails with the "independent of the schedules" part, 
because you can't release somthing that is not stabilized and tested.

Please try to get some sense back...



Andreas K. Huettel
Gentoo Linux developer 
dilfridge at
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 198 bytes
Desc: This is a digitally signed message part.
Url : 

More information about the release-team mailing list