Review Request 118795: Support versioned module imports and rationalize module dependencies

Denis Steckelmacher steckdenis at
Tue Jun 17 13:28:41 UTC 2014

This is an automatically generated e-mail. To reply, visit:

Review request for KDevelop.

Repository: kdev-qmljs


This patch is huge (2.1 MB!), but the code changes are not that big. This patch comes from two problems that the QML/JS plugin had:

* The version given in QML import statements was not used to find the correct module. An user importing QtQuick 2.0 was therefore able to see components that only appeared in QtQuick 2.1 or 2.2.
* The dependencies of the modules were a bit broken. Builtins1.qml and Builtins2.qml were "built-in" types for QtQuick 2.0 and QtQuick 1.0 respectively (not the inversion :-) ), and several modules happily depended on both files. This yielded duplicate components (Item is declared in Builtins2.qml, Builtins1.qml and QtQuick.qml that was exactly the same file as Builtins1.qml) and slowed down the parsing of the modules.

Now, the idea is to have one file per module and per version. There is therefore 5 files for QtQuick : QtQuick_1.0.qml, QtQuick_1.1.qml, QtQuick_2.0.qml, QtQuick_2.1.qml and QtQuick_2.2.qml. When the user imports a module X with a version Y, the file X_Y.qml is imported. In order to keep things simple, every file sharing the same major number (1 or 2) is exactly the same. DeclarationBuilder, when asked to parse a module file having a version X.Y, ensures that only the components having exactly the version X.Y are parsed. The others are skipped in a very fast fashion (visit() returns false and no declaration is opened). When a new Qt version comes out, updating QML/JS is as simple as running qmlplugindump and to overwrite QtQuick_2.*.qml with the output. The dump contains every declaration with the versions in which they appeared. No need to run a Python script or something like that to postprocess the dumps.

The user is now able to import QtQuick 2.1, that imports QtQuick 2.0, and can see every component that exists in QtQuick 2.1 or 2.0. The components of QtQuick 2.2 are still hidden, though. Moreover, extra modules like QtQuick.Dialog, QtQuick.Controls, etc, depend on the exact QtQuick version they require. For instance, QtQuick.Dialog depends on QtQuick 2.0 while Qt.labs.shaders depends on QtQuick 1.0.

The dependency tree of the modules is now really a tree. This avoids duplicate declarations (each declaration lives in exactly one module and one version), and greatly speeds up the parsing of module files. Filetest now takes 0.90 seconds on my computer, instead of 1.90 before this patch.

I understand that this patch is fairly complex, so take your time reviewing it :-). I've several exams at the end of this week and not much time to push this stuff, so nothing requires your immediate attention.


  codecompletion/tests/qmlcompletiontest.cpp cef0254 
  duchain/declarationbuilder.h dc132d9 
  duchain/declarationbuilder.cpp d0f8772 
  duchain/parsesession.cpp 9ef32a0 
  qmlplugins/Builtins1.qml 6677c03 
  qmlplugins/Builtins2.qml 6672239 
  qmlplugins/Qt.labs.folderlistmodel.qml ee1e58e 
  qmlplugins/Qt.labs.folderlistmodel_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/Qt.labs.gestures.qml 675eeb1 
  qmlplugins/Qt.labs.gestures_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/Qt.labs.particles.qml 9150529 
  qmlplugins/Qt.labs.particles_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/Qt.labs.settings.qml e3cc0f7 
  qmlplugins/Qt.labs.settings_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/Qt.labs.shaders.qml d357277 
  qmlplugins/Qt.labs.shaders_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtAudioEngine.qml 1416717 
  qmlplugins/QtAudioEngine_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtBluetooth.qml 9cef5cb 
  qmlplugins/QtBluetooth_5.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtBluetooth_5.2.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtMultimedia.qml 0dbf3b7 
  qmlplugins/QtMultimedia_5.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtNfc.qml e49a811 
  qmlplugins/QtNfc_5.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtNfc_5.2.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtPositioning.qml 30b203f 
  qmlplugins/QtPositioning_5.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtPositioning_5.2.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Controls.qml 6045273 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Controls_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Controls_1.1.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Dialogs.qml 5541c5c 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Dialogs_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Dialogs_1.1.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Layouts.qml 2263401 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Layouts_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.LocalStorage.qml cbf8a4d 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.LocalStorage_2.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Particles.qml 711c7a2 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Particles_2.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.PrivateWidgets.qml 9947c2b 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.PrivateWidgets_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.PrivateWidgets_1.1.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Window.qml 302e27c 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Window_2.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.Window_2.1.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.XmlListModel.qml 7e24088 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.XmlListModel_2.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick.qml e00676d 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick_1.1.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick_2.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick_2.1.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtQuick_2.2.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtSensors.qml ada6d52 
  qmlplugins/QtSensors_5.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtSensors_5.1.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/QtTest.qml 3a0e449 
  qmlplugins/QtTest_1.0.qml PRE-CREATION 
  qmlplugins/ 7723c94 
  tests/files/test.qml 86e55d1 



Two new tests are added: one ensures that the OpacityAnimator declaration exists in QtQuick 2.2, and the other ensures that OpacityAnimator doesn't exist in QtQuick 2.0 (this declaration has been introduced in QtQuick 2.2). All the other tests still pass.


Denis Steckelmacher

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <>

More information about the KDevelop-devel mailing list