Do not mark upstream bug as Resolved in kde bug system

Albert Astals Cid aacid at
Mon Feb 11 23:57:32 UTC 2013

El Dilluns, 11 de febrer de 2013, a les 12:41:26, Leon Feng va escriure:
> Today I read a blog post about "Yet Another KDE QA Failure" here:
> In my opinion, the root cause of this problem is the kde bug system. When
> we mark a bug upstream, it is resolved. But in reality, it is *not*. The
> bug is resolved only when upstream fix it.
> I have the same doubt when I first triange and mark the bug as upstream.
> This time,  the gentoo one shows how much damage a wrong status mark could
> bring up.
> The proposal: The kde bugzilla system should be changed. Do not mark  bug
> resolved when we conclude it is upstream bug. Only mark a upstream bug
> resolved when upstream actually fix it.

I disagree, there is nothing else we can do to fix the bug, so from our POV 
it's a FIXED bug.


> Feng Chao

More information about the kde-www mailing list