SUMMARY: status of website redesign
Navindra Umanee
navindra at cs.mcgill.ca
Mon Nov 25 04:42:35 UTC 2002
Here's my personal summary/proposal of the status of the webdesign.
Take it as you like.
(1) Design-wise, the new web site ostensibly looks pretty sharp and
should be nearly ready to go as a replacement for www.kde.org.
(implementation-wise and testing-wise is another matter)
This is probably up to Sebastian/Christoph/Jason/etc. A poll
should not be ruled out in case of contention.
(2) Design-wise, I think the search and location buttons should
ideally be moved out of the way. Even that "[ KDE dotNews |
Announcements | Latest Apps ]" line seems to be in the wrong
place.
I think we should also use the current design by making the
headlines of the announcements clickable and removing the extra
link at the end of each announcement.
(3) Content-wise, the missing functionality and content should be
re-added and preserved from the original design.
In particular, content-wise the dot and apps feed should
be present just like on the current page. Anything else is a step
back based on the unproven and disputed notion that KDE users
don't visit KDE.org for content, and is a matter needs to be
strongly defended by default.
(1)-(3): I'll do a mockup later if necessary.
(4) Setting the goal that all the other web sites (developer, women,
dot, apps, ...) with different functionality, expression and
maintainers should have an identical corporate design is
unreasonable, unrealistic and too *strong* a requirement.
The primary goal at this juncture should be to deploy the new
www.kde.org design, provided the approval of the maintainers/authors
of the current www.kde.org design is obtained, of course.
(5) Incremental improvements are certainly possible, and not to be
ruled out. Nothing says the design has to be 100% perfect. 95%
is okay for a first try. :-)
Anyhow, I'm not going to be responding to other random flames on this
list right now. So if I missed anything let me know separately.
Cheers,
Navin.
More information about the kde-www
mailing list