Releases in 3 months

Frank Reininghaus frank78ac at googlemail.com
Mon Jul 8 15:11:05 BST 2013


Hi,

2013/7/8 Àlex Fiestas:
> Now that kde-workspace and kdelibs are going to be frozen (which in theory
> means less work for everybody) I'd like to propose a new release schedule to
> be applied starting with 4.12.
>
> Basically the idea is to cut testing time and compensate it by keeping master
> always in a "releaseable" state, now that two major components are frozen it
> looks like it is a good time to get used to it.
>
> You can read all the proposal in:
> http://community.kde.org/KDE_Core/ReleasesProposal
>
> Before sending this email I have checked with distro people, i18n people,
> other developers and almost all of them seemed to either like or be neutral
> about it (only one exception :p) so I hope that the proposal is not a complete
> disaster.
>
> As its name indicates, it is a proposal, so please be constructive in the
> feedback, we can change as many things as we need.

I like the idea (from the Dolphin development point of view). Most of
the changes that went into master during the past months had already
been tested rather well before they were merged, and the remaining
regressions were found rather quickly by people who use the master
branch a lot. Therefore, it would have been nice if some of the
improvements could have been shipped to users sooner - quite a few
bugs that had been fixed in master (with patches that were IMHO too
intrusive for the 4.10 branch) months ago were reported again and
again.

@Laurent:you say that you have "a lot of features to implement", and
that this would not be possible with a shorter release schedule. But
wouldn't it be possible to implement some of the features for the next
version and the rest for the one after that? If you think that you
need more time to stabilize a feature in the master branch, then maybe
developing the feature in a separate branch and merge it once it's
finished might be a good idea?

Best regards,
Frank




More information about the kde-core-devel mailing list