kdereview/extragear procedure

[Cornelius Schumacher]

On Tuesday 28 March 2006 20:37, Kevin Krammer wrote:
>
> Unless I have looked into the wrong places, there is currently no real
> procedure how to do this correctly.

It would be great if the TWG would guide the creation of this procedure.

> For example I have just moved one of my projects (kabcclient) to kdereview
> when I first thought it release worthy and asked on kde-core-devel,
> kde-extra-gear and kde-pim for comments.
>
> Since there has neither been an accept nor reject reaction, I am still
> uncertain about the official project status.

I will answer to the specific request on the kde-pim mailing list.

> For the current situation I could imagine something like this:
> - developers can move their project to kdereview when they think they are
> ready for it
>
> - they announce the move on the extragear list and, if applicable, on the
> developer list for the main module of its kind, e.g. kde-multimedia for a
> multimedia application.
>
> - they wait through a four week reaction period
>
> - if there are unmet requirements the developer has to implement them until
> they are met or can opt to move directly back to playground
>
> - once all requirements are met but not earlier than this four week RFC
> period the project can move to extragear
>
> What do you think?

Sounds reasonable.

-- 
Cornelius Schumacher <schumacher at kde.org>