Review Request: New: ECMAddQCH, for generating qch & doxygen tag files

Friedrich W. H. Kossebau kossebau at kde.org
Thu Nov 24 23:00:41 UTC 2016


Hi (especially the CMake experts),

as I uploaded this to Phabricator where no group "Buildsystem" or similiar 
seems to exist yet, notifying you here manually.

Especially interested in comments on the use of "exported" CMake targets to 
allow linking between different QCH files (also naming patterns).

Cheers
Friedrich



SUMMARY

Enables generation of QCH files during a normal build,
for documenting the public API of a library.

These macros are especially done with release builds in mind,
so distributed packages (like from Linux distributions) can
include QCH files matching the version of the library and will be
also automatically updated on new versions of the libary.

Next to that these macros also support linking between different
QCH files, so a subclass from another library for which there also
is a QCH file installed will be linked to the entry in that other
QCH file.

This should be a nice supplement to online services like api.kde.org,
like Qt's own QCH files are to doc.qt.io

While QCH files from an abstract POV could be seen similar to code libraries, 
being components with
links to lookup symbols/entries in other QCH files, so the rules and code 
should be done with similar concepts,
currently CMake's target system seems bound to executable code creation.
So things like "file(EXPORT ...)" could sadly not be reused, as custom targets 
are not supported with that. Thus a custom macro had to be created for now. 
Also could I not find a way to use namespaces like KF5::, for more consistent 
target naming.

The patch also adds two variables to KDEInstallDirs.cmake for
controlling where the QCH (and respective doxygen tag files) are
installed. The QTQCHDIR variant allows to install QCH files for
Qt-extending libraries into the same folder where Qt's own QCH
files are, so Qt Assistant & other QCH viewer pick up them automatically.

Open questions:
a) target system for exporting/importing done in a sane way? Better name 
pattern for the QCH targets than xxx_QCH (see the targets created for Qt, like 
Qt5Core_QCH)?

b) sharing metadata with kapidox
Initially I placed these macros into the kapidox module, as this seems the
logic place. And would match what kdoctools does for user manuals.
Just, that would create a build dependency on kapidox which complicates usage
a little. Having these macros in ECM delivers them with no extra effort
needed.
The data in metainfo.yaml is partially duplicated with the data feed into
the macros. How to deduplicate that is still open. Especially with the need
to not depend on external data sources like identify.kde.org.

Issues:

* released current doxygen versions broken and miss to include some files with 
generated QCH (https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=773693), fixed only 
in doxygen development version
* Qt Assistant often only built with QTextBrowser, while doxygen uses lots of 
HTML5 (incl. hardcoded JavaScript) (https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?
id=773715), needs e.g. distributions to use QtWebKit to work
* inter-QCH links do not work in KDevelop currently (see https://bugs.kde.org/
show_bug.cgi?id=372747)

Future work:

* avoid need to explicitly list all linked QCH targets, have something like 
public link interfaces (gets complicated with mixes of versioned and 
unversioned linking possibly)

More details/background info at
https://frinring.wordpress.com/2016/09/27/adding-api-dox-generation-to-the-build-by-cmake-macros/


More information about the Kde-buildsystem mailing list