[gcompris-devel] More music activity comments, based on git commit 672eb8eecd 12.09.2012

[Peter Albrecht]

Hi!

On 18.09.2012 01:03, Bruno Coudoin wrote:
> Some more comment on this long message.

Maybe I should have posted each issue in a separate
email. ;)


> Le samedi 15 septembre 2012 à 23:32 +0200, Peter Albrecht a écrit :
>> You added a bonus at the end of level 2. How about adding a
>> bonus, when level 1 is finished, too?
> 
> Done.

Perfect!


>>>>> ** Name that note
>> Steps to reproduce:
>> 1. start the activity
>> 2. goto level 2
>> 3. I'am asked to name a "G"
>> 4. clicking on the note on the left, I hear a sound: lets
>> say "de"
>> 5. clicking answer alternative "F" in the middle of the
>> screen, I hear a sound like "da"; clicking "C" in the
>> middle, I hear a sound like "do"; clicking "G" in the
>> middle, I hear a sound like "de", exactly the sound, I hear
>> when clicking the note "G" on the left side of the screen;
>> in short: different answers, different sounds
>> 6. now I answer this question correctly with "G" and "OK"
>> 7. repeat steps 3. to 6. until you are asked for an "upper C"
>> 8. now I click on the note on the left side of the screen
>> and hear a sound like "di"
>>
> 
> Thanks a lot for your detailed instruction. I found the bug and made a
> fix. Now I keep the 2 'C' buttons on the right, it is up the the
> children to find the right one. I think it is less confusing after all,
> at least, the code is cleaner.

The same-sound-bug is fixed. Thanks!

The "2-C-problem" is quite difficult. I agree, code is
cleaner, if showing two "C" buttons. But at level 4 you
don't get sounds, when clicking on the buttons.
So children don't have a chance do identify the correct
solution.
Their only chance is to try one with a 50:50 chance. This
might be a little bit frustrating.

According to wikipedia
 >
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Common_Octave_Naming_Systems.png
we could name the notes c' and c". But this would be way too
complicated for children.

Please have a look at the following pull request:
 > https://github.com/bdoin/GCompris/pull/6

Regards,
	Peter