[Uml-devel] [Bug 56184] Umbrello XMI file format doesn't conform with uml13.dtd

[Oliver Kellogg]

------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are the assignee for the bug, or are watching the assignee.
        
http://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=56184        




------- Additional Comments From okellogg users sourceforge net  2004-10-29 23:12 -------
>From Ivan Porres (developer of Coral, http://sourceforge.net/projects/coral)

<quote>
 The main problem with the generated XMI is that it does not add the names of
 the properties in compositions. For example:
 
 Umbrello generates:

 <UML:Model>
    <UML:Stereotype visibility="public" xmi.id="13" name="actor" />
    <UML:Stereotype visibility="public" xmi.id="15" name="class" />
    <UML:Stereotype visibility="public" xmi.id="17" name="datatype" />
    <UML:DataType stereotype="17" visibility="public" xmi.id="16" name="void" />
   <UML:Class visibility="public" xmi.id="6" name="UMLListView" >
 ...

 When it should generate:

 <UML:Model>
   <UML:ModelElement.stereotype>
    <UML:Stereotype visibility="public" xmi.id="13" name="actor" />
    <UML:Stereotype visibility="public" xmi.id="15" name="class" />
    <UML:Stereotype visibility="public" xmi.id="17" name="datatype" />
   </UML:ModelElement.stereotype>

   <UML:Namespace.ownedElement>

   <UML:DataType stereotype="17" visibility="public" xmi.id="16" name="void" />
   <UML:Class visibility="public" xmi.id="6" name="UMLListView" >
    <UML:Classifier.feature>
     <UML:Operation visibility="public" xmi.id="77" type="16" name="contentsMousePressEvent" />
     <UML:Operation visibility="public" xmi.id="80" type="16" name="popupMenuSel" />
     <UML:Operation visibility="public" xmi.id="32" type="16"
name="addNewItem" />
     <UML:Operation visibility="public" xmi.id="53" type="16"
name="slotItemRenamed" />
     <UML:Operation visibility="public" xmi.id="56" type="16"
name="createChildUMLObject" />
    </UML:Classifier.feature>


 Also, Umbrello does not conform to the UML 1.3 standard. IIRC, A UML 1.3
 Operation does not have a property called type. Check the standard.  Is this
 the return type of the operation? This is modeled by creating a  Parameter
 with direction "return" and the desired type.
</quote>

Implemented these suggestions and updated the sample file
http://uml.sourceforge.net/developers/CreateOperationUsingRightMousebuttonInListView.xmi