Review Request 126036: Update wallpaper package with plasma 5.5 wallpaper contest

Wed Nov 11 23:26:13 UTC 2015

-----------------------------------------------------------
This is an automatically generated e-mail. To reply, visit:
https://git.reviewboard.kde.org/r/126036/#review88274
-----------------------------------------------------------

I can't seem to create folders so I'll post my feedback here with my long years
semi-pro photography hat on:

* Colorful Cups - to me it doesn't really work as a wallpaper. It's a nice~ish photo,
  but the high-contrast edges of the cups are clashing with the icons and the icon labels
  which doesn't look very good. Overall the theme of the photo does "not feel right" for
  a desktop. Discard (from me).

* Evening Glow - the photo feels unbalanced, there's a high brigthness in the sky which
  overshines the main theme of the photo (the boats), which are in turn much more shadow-y
  and not entirely sharp (it looks like a hand-held hdr). Discard (from me).

* PSX_20150910_181318 (those white flowers) - it's not a very good photo and the blossoms
  are not that pretty. Discard (from me).

* PSX_20150910_182607 (the shack in front of the forest) - its strange softfocus is imo
  not very good, the trees lack details, the shack is out of focus and the subject matter
  is also not very good for a desktop wallpaper. Perhaps if the lawn mover wasn't there
  it could be nice, but other than that it's the same case as the colorful cups one.
  Just "doesn't feel right" (plus the low quality). Discard (from me).

* Group discards/By the water - I believe that's the a submission? It's not bad, has a bit
  of noise in it which could be reduced, but other than that, I'd bring it back.

* Discarded by Uri/Darkest hour - if we could tweak that photo, I think it could be nice.

With the rest I pretty much agree.

- Martin Klapetek

On Nov. 11, 2015, 11:56 p.m., andreas kainz wrote:
> 
> -----------------------------------------------------------
> This is an automatically generated e-mail. To reply, visit:
> https://git.reviewboard.kde.org/r/126036/
> -----------------------------------------------------------
> 
> (Updated Nov. 11, 2015, 11:56 p.m.)
> 
> 
> Review request for Plasma.
> 
> 
> Repository: plasma-workspace-wallpapers
> 
> 
> Description
> -------
> 
> As you know I start an wallpaper contest for plasma 5.5. The VDG make an preselection and I hope the Plasma team will give feedback which wallpaper should be included in the plasma 5.5 extra wallpaper package
> 
> 
> Diffs
> -----
> 
>   Alps/contents/images/1280x1024.jpg c295fdc 
>   Alps/contents/images/1280x800.jpg b6edfe7 
>   Alps/contents/images/1440x900.jpg c94bcaa 
>   Alps/contents/images/1600x1200.jpg e09e592 
>   Alps/contents/images/1638x1024.jpg 0c06524 
>   Alps/contents/images/1680x1050.jpg 6c96d86 
>   Alps/contents/images/1920x1080.jpg 4b974d4 
>   Alps/contents/images/1920x1200.jpg 677a6aa 
>   Alps/contents/images/2560x1600.jpg 9bac171 
>   Alps/contents/images/2560x2440.jpg 2075d9b 
>   Alps/contents/images/640x480.jpg 7f6a74e 
>   Alps/contents/images/800x600.jpg 09a604d 
>   Alps/contents/screenshot.jpg 54c27e9 
>   Alps/metadata.desktop 002dba2 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/1280x1024.jpg 1dddd95 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/1280x800.jpg 5d9b62c 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/1440x900.jpg e2677a4 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/1600x1200.jpg da10f13 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/1638x1024.jpg 76c6fc5 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/1680x1050.jpg 79a298a 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/1920x1080.jpg 20e763b 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/1920x1200.jpg 39c4a4e 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/2560x1440.jpg 2a32989 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/2560x1600.jpg de59380 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/640x480.jpg 1d35499 
>   BlueFlower/contents/images/800x600.jpg f9e9e29 
>   BlueFlower/contents/screenshot.jpg 7cdf224 
>   BlueFlower/metadata.desktop ed2a89a 
>   Dance_of_the_Spirits/contents/images/1280x1024.jpg 458a9d3 
>   Dance_of_the_Spirits/contents/images/1280x800.jpg 099dba5 
>   Dance_of_the_Spirits/contents/images/1440x900.jpg 710aad5 
>   Dance_of_the_Spirits/contents/images/1600x1200.jpg 369e081 
>   Dance_of_the_Spirits/contents/images/1920x1080.jpg d47bc94 
>   Dance_of_the_Spirits/contents/images/1920x1200.jpg 9fa01ac 
>   Dance_of_the_Spirits/contents/images/2560x1440.jpg 060148e 
>   Dance_of_the_Spirits/contents/images/2560x1600.jpg 28515f1 
>   Dance_of_the_Spirits/contents/screenshot.png 9b9c0c5 
>   Dance_of_the_Spirits/metadata.desktop 0b2f6c9 
>   GereatHeron/contents/images/1280x1024.jpg 8fa95fb 
>   GereatHeron/contents/images/1280x800.jpg 5f7e924 
>   GereatHeron/contents/images/1440x900.jpg 0336115 
>   GereatHeron/contents/images/1600x1200.jpg 6659dd6 
>   GereatHeron/contents/images/1680x1050.jpg 0243a4d 
>   GereatHeron/contents/images/1920x1080.jpg e3c04c0 
>   GereatHeron/contents/images/1920x1200.jpg 34ced65 
>   GereatHeron/contents/images/2560x1440.jpg ed5a835 
>   GereatHeron/contents/images/2560x1600.jpg ccba2c0 
>   GereatHeron/contents/images/640x480.jpg 8e30b41 
>   GereatHeron/contents/images/800x600.jpg fb956a3 
>   GereatHeron/contents/screenshot.jpg 25a514d 
>   GereatHeron/metadata.desktop 4274fbd 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/1280x1024.jpg 83ac796 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/1280x800.jpg 45f8cb1 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/1440x900.jpg 1c28a72 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/1600x1200.jpg e84d18d 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/1638x1024.jpg dc9e4a3 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/1680x1050.jpg 89ed042 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/1920x1080.jpg be2a31e 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/1920x1200.jpg 409dbcf 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/2560x1440.jpg 70237d9 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/2560x1600.jpg d966604 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/640x480.jpg 1302268 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/images/800x600.jpg 14de9cb 
>   Landmannalaugar/contents/screenshot.jpg 46be560 
>   Landmannalaugar/metadata.desktop ded464b 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/1280x1024.jpg 3116e33 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/1280x800.jpg 7ac2b77 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/1440x900.jpg b13f4a2 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/1600x1200.jpg 840cba1 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/1638x1024.jpg bffefaa 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/1680x1050.jpg d1a0b2f 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/1920x1080.jpg 072cf23 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/1920x1200.jpg 729f488 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/2560x1440.jpg 19fd12d 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/2560x1600.jpg fbfdca5 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/800x600.jpg a09fbac 
>   Tauplitz/contents/images/Untitled.jpg 26225ca 
>   Tauplitz/contents/screenshot.jpg d98b905 
>   Tauplitz/metadata.desktop 29638c6 
> 
> Diff: https://git.reviewboard.kde.org/r/126036/diff/
> 
> 
> Testing
> -------
> 
> all wallpapers are located in the share.kde.org folder
> 
> https://share.kde.org/index.php/s/fvPmEjcZOR2Ya2u
> 
> move discard wallpapers in an separate folder with your username. you can also move wallpapers from an discard folder to the main folder. all wallpapers in the main folder will shiped with 5.5
> 
> 
> Thanks,
> 
> andreas kainz
> 
>

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mail.kde.org/pipermail/plasma-devel/attachments/20151111/72e1e0ba/attachment.html>