Icon copyright issues for 1.0

Ralf Nolden Ralf.Nolden at post.rwth-aachen.de
Tue Aug 10 07:16:02 BST 1999


John Zedlewski wrote:
> 
> Hmm, I was using MSVC++ today at work, and I realized that a few of the
> toolbar icons for KDev are still the ones that were copied directly from a
> screenshot of the Microsoft IDE.  While I don't think anybody is in danger
> of being sued today, I'd point out that the main KDE folks have been
> prevented from using the name "Trash" for the trashcan, because that's an
> Apple copyright.  Clearly, actually lifting MS icons would be even more
> obvious and it would be a shame to have to make the change AFTER 1.0.  So
> does anybody have any ideas for new icons?  Specifically, the "Search in
> Files", "Dialog Builder" and "Workspace" icons are very obvious.  I've
> always though that the "Workspace" icon should show a tree view anyways,
> instead of whatever-the-hell they have on there.  Maybe we can find
> replacements among the existing set of KDE mini-icons?
> --JZ

Well, the icons were acutally made on the fly. I made a screenshot but
painted them myself. A pixel-to-pixel comparison makes that clear ;-)

But if anyone has better ones, please take the time and send
suggestions.

I talked with Torsten Rahn (artist team) about that issue on the
Linuxtag exhibition about that and we came to the point to make further
icons completely ourselves.

Ralf






More information about the KDevelop mailing list