[kdepim] [Bug 342015] cannot compile libkdepim without baloo

[kavol]

https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=342015

--- Comment #4 from kavol <kavol at seznam.cz> ---
(In reply to Laurent Montel from comment #3)
...
> Baloo developper has created this patch.
> So it was required and there is never optional so no it's not a bug.
> Perhaps you need a feature but it's not a bug because never supported.

ahem, sorry, but I still do not follow ...

there is a discrepancy between the statement and the actual code

so one of them is wrong - "buggy"

and as the statement is part of a broader discussion, not just a random
thought, I'd say the bug is in the code and not in the statement

it's not a feature in the sense of "new functionality", it is a problem with
already existing code

so probably reassigning this to the actual author of the code to make it
compliant with what he says the code should do would be better than just
closing the bugreport with something like "he coded it this way so it should be
so" - if I get your words right

(if not, I apologise; also, I don't know much about processes in this bugzilla
instance, if the assignee is tied to the component and cannot be changed or
whatever ... I just present my POV which doesn't have to be best due to missing
context)

> So I will look at for kf5

cool, thanks

> but not for 4.14. I will not break all for it.
> If you don't want it. remove akonadi_baloo_indexer.

ok, I guess I can live with that as long as `rm /usr/bin/baloo*` doesn't break
anything I use

...
> I don't know why it reported it as optional but it's not my problem.
> If you want to open a bug report about it, report to kdelibs

ok, bug 342477

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.