[Bug 145179] New: Thank you Kmail for these last 5 years

[Verdi March]

------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are the assignee for the bug, or are watching the assignee.
         
http://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=145179         
           Summary: Thank you Kmail for these last 5 years
           Product: kmail
           Version: unspecified
          Platform: SuSE RPMs
        OS/Version: Linux
            Status: UNCONFIRMED
          Severity: normal
          Priority: NOR
         Component: general
        AssignedTo: kdepim-bugs kde org
        ReportedBy: cincaipatron gmx net


Version:            (using KDE KDE 3.5.6)
Installed from:    SuSE RPMs

Firstly, I truly apologize for sending this message through the
bug report system, as I don't want to subscribe to a milis just
for sending one email.

I would like to thank KMail developers and community members
for this good software. Unfortunately, recent incidents of IMAP
accesses, in which I just lost a lots of valuable emails, have
made me to switch to Thunderbird. Please consider this report as
my feedback to KMail.

Until today, I've been using KMail for about 5 since 2002 (suse
7.2). I've tried out Thunderbird, and it is very very fast for IMAP.
But, I still persist using KMail because usability wise (actually I
really hate uttering this slogan), KMail is very convenient and
effective.

Examples where KMail is, at least for me, better than Thunderbird:
1. goto next/previous message using left/right arrow.
2. sweep through read-once-and-then-removed threads with
   keystrokes only. This is mainly because when I "select/block"
   messages (with shift+left_click or Shift+left_arrow), it still
   displays the focused message in the message preview pane. 
3. Globally enabled threaded display for all folders. In Thunderbird,
   each folder needs to be configured individually.

My familiarity with KMail makes me unwilling to switch to Thunderbird
eventhough it is faster on accessing IMAP. Even if I've experienced
more crashes when accessing IMAP servers.

However, in just a couple of hours, I lost many of my valuable emails,
all due to IMAP operations:
1. I **copied** messages from one IMAP folder to another IMAP
   folder. KMail then crashes. After restarting KMail, I attempted to
   repeat the copying because I wanted to be sure all messages have
   been copied. So I deleted all messages from the new folder and
   went to the old folder. The results: old folder contained zero
   messages, which suggests that KMail actually performed **move**
   operations instead of copy operations
   I tested copy/move with Thunderbird, and it really performs copy
   as copy, and move as move.

2. I have one IMAP folder, as a parent, consisting of many IMAP
   subfolders. I renamed the parent folder. After that, all my
   subfolders disappeared. Those subfolders are emails containing
   attached documents, presentations slides, and papers in pdf.
   They're now gone :(
   PS: appreciated for suggestions on how to recover those subfolders.


While I'm still feeling uneasy about the above incidents, I do
realize and appreciate the efforts that KMail team has put.
I hope that for KDE4, KMail can improve its IMAP supports. More
importantly, do not cause lost of emails.

Peace :)