[Bug 95385] oggs are played too fast

[Cyrille Dunant]

------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are the assignee for the bug, or are watching the assignee.
         
http://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=95385         




------- Additional Comments From cyrille.dunant epfl ch  2005-02-04 11:25 -------
> The reporter is wrong about his mpeglib and arts assumptions. Both juk and
> noatun use exactly the same code when playing files through arts, it's
> either mpeglib, aKode or arts-builtin ogg support (yes, there's three of
> them, don't ask me why). Furthermore he was talking about xine playback not
> working in amarok, why should this be a kdemultimedia bug either?

OK, I'm the reporter, and unless I am half crazy, the sound is different when 
playing the _same_ mp3 with noatun or juk. The natural assumption is that 
they use different decoders. Since I _know_ (I tested that) that akode plays 
it wrong, _and_ xine plays it wrong _and_ mpeglib (I will say mpeglib, by 
elimination, but that is using noatun) plays it right, I assume there is
 - a bug in xine-lib
 - a bug in akode
 - the two outputs are identical to my ear, thus I tend to assume the bug 
might have the same nature. Of course, I don't _know_ that.

> As long as the buggy component has not been found I suggest keeping this
> with amarok instead of moving it into another random product.

Anyways, thanks for taking time to look at this issue.

 -- Cyrille Dunant