Clipboard for the dummies
Maks Orlovich
mo002j at mail.rochester.edu
Sat Nov 2 16:19:16 GMT 2002
> > - explicit actions like 'copy link location' set selection, even
> > if there's no text selected (I couldn't find any such action in any Gtk2
> > app to test, Havoc?)
>
> This is a very bad idea because it mixes two concepts
> seperated cleanly to allow a clear mental model to form in the user's
> mind. RMB-paste should be enough. (This feature could be optional
> "for power users" if provided at all.)
That's unfortunately simply a neccessity for interoperability in one specific
scenario: trying to copy a link from a web-browser to a terminal that's not a
KDE or Gnome app (i.e. usually Eterm, and probably Rxvt, Xterm, etc.) --
since these offer no convenient way, AFAIK, to paste CLIPBOARD. And the
reason I am concerned about this particular case, BTW, is that a user
reported a bug with clipboard setting that showed up in this scenario, and
considered it important enough to do a lot of work in helping to debug it.
Also, it can be argued that it is consistent, and that only setting CLIPBOARD
would be inconsistent -- i.e. all the time when you select some text and do
explicit copy, both CLIPBOARD and PRIMARY are set; but if one does it the way
you consider proper, only CLIPBOARD is set on an explicit copy, which can be
a surprise.
More information about the kde-core-devel
mailing list