[PATCH]: menu button in window deco

Matthias Elter m_elter at t-online.de
Mon Jul 22 18:04:57 BST 2002


On Monday 22 July 2002 18:22, Matthias Ettrich wrote:
> > Make that two for removing it. I did not know about this double click
> > "feature" until now and I agree that it's braindead and very confusing if
> > it happens by accident.
>
> The fact you didn't notice it (after 5 years of using KDE and probably more
> years of using Windows or CDE) is a strong indication that it does not
> happen by accident.

The reason that I did not notice it in 5 years probably is that I never ever 
use that menu at all.

> There is little point in removing it, unless you deliberately want to
> confuse the portion of users that expect it to be there.

I see your point but I guess we should try to find out what causes more 
confusion, newbies accidentially closing applications or power users missing 
a beloved feature. Perhaps we should disable it in CVS for a while and see 
how many flame mails come in. Comparing the number of bug reports to the 
number of flame mails of course would be anything but representative given 
the limited "test set". It still might result in a good guess?

> Doubleclick for closing Windows has been a standard with many window
> managers, including Windows 3.x, mwm and CDE. Before the 'x' button, it was
> the fastest way of closing windows.

Even standards are revised from time to time.

Greetings,
Matthias





More information about the kde-core-devel mailing list