[k3b] [Bug 257602] K3B cannot burn Blurays (or AVCHDs)

[Thomas Schmitt]

https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=257602

--- Comment #17 from Thomas Schmitt <scdbackup at gmx.net> ---
Hi,

please excuse my clear language in this case:

dev.dliw at gmail.com wrote:
> The real problem is, that Linux still is unable to create UDF 2.50 or
> UDF 2.60 images:

When it comes to data storage on optical media, UDF has no practical
advantage over ISO 9660 with Rock Ridge, zisofs, and AAIP, except maybe
that you can circumvent the 25 year old ISO 9660 drivers of the BSD Unixes.

It is really only about DVD video and BD video. No other reason to use UDF,
unless you need to read large files by BSD Unix and don't want to extract
them by userland programs.

> This is also bad for plain Bluray data disks. AFAIK especially for BD-RE 
> these higher UDF versions are essential for a long lifetime.

Any use of BD-RE which is not mainly sequential will soon kill media and/or 
drive. The whole promise of Defect Management to replace overworked blocks 
simply does not yield good results in practice.
Keep read-write filesystem drivers away from BD-RE. Use a filesystem
image formatter and a burn program, like K3B does. If you do so, then it
does not matter to the medium what kind of filesystem the image contains.

Have a nice day :)

Thomas

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.