Absolutely awesome plasmoid idea: the playlist itself

Jud Craft craftjml at gmail.com
Mon Dec 22 01:26:39 UTC 2008


Well, it's worth noting that not all customizability is complex; or
perhaps, complexity can possibly be made more intuitive.

For example, if I give you an interface that has several rectangles on
it, and say "You can choose a color for any rectangle", that's not too
complicated.  Compare to this:  you have several different regions of
the window, and you can choose a task for each one.

So here's an idea to bring some cohesion to the plasmoid organization:
 perhaps in addition to the four customizable plasmoid pages, there
would be plasmoid pages would be devoted to a certain task; the
collection page, the playlist page, etc.  You can set any pane/view to
any page, at any time.  And there are special "Task" pages:
Collection, Playlist, Service, etc.

This gets around the "breaking the system" problem of missing
essential plasmoids:  a "task" page has a required plasmoid, while the
Customizable ones do not.  For example, a Playlist page must always
have a playlist plasmoid.

It must be trivially easy to switch page types, and quick:  better
than the "left/right" switch to go between the customizable pages.
For example, a button (similar to the Add Plasmoid button) could popup
a list of tasks (Collection, Playlist, Service, Custom), similar to
how the Add Plasmoid pops up a list of plasmoids to choose from.

(For something even more noticeable, take how when you drag a song to
the Plasmoid area, giant icons with common tasks ("Add to Playlist",
"Load", "Get Related Songs") appear.  Perhaps each pane can have a
Task button that will pop up a similar menu with the different types:
"Playlist", "Collection", service types, etc.)

In addition to setting a task, you could then add additional plasmoids
to a page (which would require good resizing).  For example, I could
turn my panel on the right into a Playlist Page, and a Playlist
plasmoid would be automatically added.  Then I could add a Song Info
plasmoid to it.  The benefits of this approach are that you could have
a dynamic two-pane setup:  I could have a Collection Page on the left
page containing a collection plasmoid, and a Playlist page on the
right pane containing a playlist and the Song Info plasmoid.

But at any moment, with the flick of the Task button, I could turn
switch the right pane into a Collection Page as well, and then manage
my collection with a true split-pane layout.  At any time, I could
flip that back to my Playlist page.


For this, each pane becomes a view onto a particular Plasmoid page.
This is comparable to how Aaron Seigo eventually wants
Plasma-workspace to function:  the ability to have several different
views that each support a certain activity.

The difference is, with Workspace, you can only have one view at a
time open.  Perhaps with Amarok's view panes, you could have two (or
three!) different views at once, each supporting a different Task.
(There could even be a CD burning Task.  In fact, an extension could,
in addition to creating a custom Plasmoid, also create a Task page to
go with that Plasmoid).

Mismanaged, this whole plasmoid ruckus could become hugely
complicated, no doubt.  Just thought I'd push out some more
brainstorming.



More information about the Amarok mailing list